Season 23 of American Idol has officially come to a close — and while some fans celebrate, others are left heartbroken. In a stunning finale that drew a record-breaking 26 million votes, John Foster, one of the season’s biggest fan favorites, took home second place, despite being widely considered the front-runner.

 John Foster: A Voice, A Writer, A True Country Artist

Throughout the season, John Foster stood out not only for his powerful vocals, but also for his songwriting talent. One of his original songs, performed during the competition, has already become a fan-favorite hit — a rare accomplishment for an Idol contestant. But even that wasn’t enough to secure the top spot.

Advertisements

1. 

2. 1. Now Playing

      Up NextMeet the 2022 Tony Nominees: THE MUSIC MAN's Sutton Foster

      1:40

   2. Now Playing

      Up NextDisaster For Biden After Debate – He Is Finished

      3:46

   3. Now Playing

      Up NextCome on now, Give Yourself a Break!

      9:20

   4. Now Playing

      Up NextBWW Exclusive: Allison Frasca Gets WICKED on The Broadway Break(down)!

      2:42

   5. Now Playing

      Up NextMeet the 2022 Tony Nominees: THE MUSIC MAN's Sutton Foster

      1:40

   6. Now Playing

      Up NextVideo: David Foster Joins BOOP! THE MUSICAL Curtain Call

      2:26

   7. Now Playing

      Up NextEpic ping pong challenge, David breaks the record

      2:09

   8. Now Playing

      Up NextCarabao Semi and The Break: Media Matters

      56:59

   9. Now Playing

      Up NextProjection & Blame: How to Break These Relationship Habits

      3:14

   10. Now Playing

       Up Next Max shatters the cubing world record

       2:54

While Foster had nearly every advantage — vocal strength, country authenticity, and songwriting credibility — the crown ultimately went to Jamal Roberts, sparking passionate reactions across social media.

Advertisements

 A Historic Season with 26 Million Votes

This year’s finale wasn’t just emotional — it was historic. Over 26 million votes were cast, making it the most-voted finale in recent years, doubling the total from last season. American Idol clearly remains a powerful platform for discovering and launching tomorrow’s stars.

 Controversies & Fan Reactions

Advertisements

Despite the glamour and talent on display, Season 23 wasn’t without drama. Several contestants spoke out during the season about issues behind the scenes, adding to an undercurrent of controversy that continued into the finale. And after the results were announced, the conversation only intensified.

 John Foster Breaks Silence with Emotional Facebook Message

Just moments after the show ended, John Foster took to Facebook to share a heartfelt message with his fans — a reminder of his gratitude and grace:

“Man, what a true blessing to share this Idol stage with so many incredible heroes, both new faces and legends. I’m beyond thankful, and I can’t wait to keep making music for y’all as long as the good Lord lets me. Thank you from the bottom of my heart – times a million. 🙏❤️”

The message quickly went viral, drawing praise for Foster’s humility and strength in the face of disappointment.

 Watch the Final Performances — You Decide Who Deserved to Win

We’ve included both finalists’ grand finale performances below. Take a moment to watch them and decide for yourself: Who truly deserved the title of American Idol 2025?

👇 Let us know your thoughts in the comments on our Facebook page!

John Foster Performance:

Advertisements

Jamal Roberts Performane: