WWE’s SummerSlam 2024 delivered countless memorable moments, but none were quite as viral as country star Jelly Roll’s shocking in-ring appearance, where he chokeslammed Austin Theory in a segment that lit up social media. Fast forward to June 2025, the saga continues as Austin Theory, the former United States Champion, has thrown down the gauntlet, challenging Jelly Roll to a rematch on an upcoming episode of SmackDown. Theory, still stinging from the viral humiliation, claims he was caught off guard, but Jelly Roll’s five-word response has left fans roaring with laughter and anticipation for what could be another iconic WWE moment.
The original encounter at SummerSlam saw Jelly Roll, real name Jason Bradley DeFord, step into the ring after Theory and his A-Town Down Under partner Grayson Waller insulted the Cleveland crowd and mocked the singer. Armed with a steel chair, Jelly Roll delivered chair shots to both, then hoisted Theory for a towering chokeslam, followed by a John Cena-inspired Five-Knuckle Shuffle alongside The Miz and R-Truth. The moment trended worldwide, with fans and even WWE legend John Cena praising Jelly Roll’s natural charisma. Theory, however, insists it was a fluke. During a heated promo on the June 20, 2025, episode of SmackDown, the 27-year-old wrestler declared, “Last time he got lucky; I was careless and unfocused. If he agrees, I’ll show him what real strength is. Jelly Roll, step back in my ring, and I’ll put you down for good.”
Jelly Roll, who has since expressed catching the “wrestling bug” and even considered buying a ring, didn’t hesitate to respond. In a video posted to his X account on June 21, 2025, the Grammy-nominated artist, grinning ear to ear, delivered a five-word quip that had fans in stitches: “Bring it, Theory—bigger chair coming!” The playful taunt, referencing his SummerSlam chair shots, sparked a frenzy online, with hashtags like #JellyRollVsTheory and #BiggerChair trending. Fans flooded X with memes, one joking, “Jelly Roll’s chair deserves a Hall of Fame induction!” Another wrote, “Theory’s about to eat another chokeslam and a side of biscuits!”
Theory, known for his athleticism and knack for selling moves, revealed on the “Battleground” podcast that he pitched the original chokeslam to WWE’s Triple H, convincing him over a planned scoop slam to make Jelly Roll look like a “rock star.” His willingness to elevate the moment earned him praise, but now, Theory’s ego seems bruised. Sources backstage report he’s pushing for a rematch to reclaim his credibility, potentially at SummerSlam 2025 in Tampa Bay. WWE is reportedly open to the idea, given Jelly Roll’s massive draw—his SummerSlam appearance helped boost viewership and his music’s integration drove record streams for “Liar.”
Jelly Roll, meanwhile, has leaned into his newfound WWE fandom, training sporadically and hinting at more appearances. His response suggests he’s game, but fans wonder if he’ll bring another surprise, like a celebrity ally or a new move. As the feud heats up, the WWE Universe is buzzing—will Theory get his revenge, or will Jelly Roll’s “bigger chair” steal the spotlight again? One thing’s certain: this rematch promises to be a wild ride, blending wrestling’s intensity with Jelly Roll’s infectious charm.
