Following months of speculation, country music superstar and former American Idol winner, Carrie Underwood, has confirmed that she wonโt be returning to the show in a permanent capacity. In a recent interview, Underwood clarified her future with the reality competition that launched her career, explaining that sheโs prioritizing new projects and family life.
Underwoodโs journey with American Idol began in 2005 when she auditioned in St. Louis, Missouri. Her powerful voice and small-town charm quickly won over judges and audiences, leading her to become the season four champion. Her win paved the way for a stellar career that includes numerous albums, multiple Grammy awards, and a slew of chart-topping hits.
Over the years, Underwood has maintained a strong connection to the show, making frequent guest appearances as a mentor and performer. However, her busy schedule and growing business ventures, including her fitness line CALIA, have led fans to question her long-term involvement.
A Shifting Focus
Underwoodโs statement comes after her most recent mentorship role during the showโs 22nd season. Fans noted a more introspective tone from the star, which fueled rumors of her potential departure. Additionally, her packed 2025 scheduleโwhich includes her Las Vegas residency, Reflection, and work on a new albumโsuggested her focus was shifting.
Speaking to Entertainment Weekly, Underwood put the rumors to rest. While she expressed her deep love for the show, calling it โhome,โ she explained that she is in a new phase of her life. โI am currently in a stage of my life where I am investigating what lies ahead,โ she said. โThe schedule for American Idol is very demandingโฆ I do not intend to return to the show in a formal capacity, such as a judge or a full-time mentor.โ
However, she did not rule out future appearances entirely. Underwood added with a smile, โIf they called me to do a performance or pop in for a special episode, Iโd love toโฆ I will forever be a member of the American Idol family.โ
Industry Reactions
Underwoodโs decision comes at a time when American Idol is actively searching for a replacement for departing judge Katy Perry. Sources close to the production team say Underwood was on a shortlist of potential candidates, alongside other Idol alumni like Kelly Clarkson and Jennifer Hudson. However, her demanding schedule and a desire for creative flexibility made a long-term commitment difficult.
An unnamed source told Variety that while Underwood was a โdream candidate,โ securing her for a full season would mean competing with her music and family interests, which was a tough situation.
The Road Ahead
Despite her step back from American Idol, thereโs no sign of Underwood slowing down. Her Las Vegas residency has been a massive success, and sheโs hinted that her upcoming album will explore more personal themes. She is also reportedly in talks for a new television project, further expanding her brand beyond music.
Underwoodโs choice reflects a growing trend among top artists who prioritize creative independence over the demanding schedules of television shows. While the show will miss her regular presence, her fans can still look forward to whatโs next in her ever-evolving career.
