When Gabby Barrett first stepped onto the American Idol stage in 2018, she was a wide-eyed teenager chasing a dream—one shared by countless hopefuls before her, including the show’s most successful alum, Carrie Underwood. What began as a classic mentor-mentee relationship has blossomed into genuine friendship, as Barrett recently revealed in interviews that she now considers Underwood a true friend.
From Idol Mentorship to Texting Friends
Barrett’s journey on American Idol Season 16 was marked by standout performances and powerful vocals, earning her a third-place finish and the attention of Underwood, the 2005 champion and country music superstar. Underwood’s guidance during the show’s Top 5 round—where contestants sang from her songbook—left a deep impression on Barrett, who delivered a show-stopping rendition of “Church Bells.”
Fast forward to 2020, and Barrett’s breakout single “I Hope” had soared to No. 1 on the country charts, signaling her arrival as a major new voice. As reported by People Magazine and Go Country 105, Underwood was quick to reach out, texting Barrett a heartfelt congratulations. “When ‘I Hope’ went No. 1, Carrie texted me congrats,” Barrett shared. “We keep in touch, and I think I can call her friend now. That’s pretty cool!”
Finding Her Own Voice—and Carrie’s Support
Barrett’s powerful vocals and crossover appeal have drawn frequent comparisons to Underwood. Far from shying away, Barrett has embraced the parallels. “It’s an absolute compliment,” she told Taste of Country. But Underwood herself has encouraged Barrett to embrace her own unique sound, noting, “You have more grit and you have soul and a real R&B flare in your voice. It’s much different than mine.”
That support helped Barrett navigate industry expectations and public perception, while also bolstering her confidence. Underwood’s faith in Barrett’s future was clear early on, predicting her post-Idol success—a prediction proven true with the record-breaking debut of Barrett’s album Goldmine in June 2020.
More Than Music: Motherhood Advice and Personal Support
Their friendship extends beyond music industry advice. In 2021, as Barrett prepared to welcome her first child, daughter Baylah, Underwood was among those who reached out. Barrett told Good Morning America that Underwood was “extremely nice” and offered, “If you ever need any advice or whatnot, just let me know.” Barrett took her up on it, grateful for Underwood’s willingness to share her experience as a fellow musician and mother.
A Full-Circle Friendship
Barrett’s story is one of growth, resilience, and the power of mentorship that evolves. What started as a relationship forged in the competitive world of American Idol has grown into a friendship grounded in mutual respect, encouragement, and support—on stage and off. For Gabby Barrett, that means having a country superstar in her corner, and, as she puts it, “I think I can call her a friend now.” For fans, it’s a reminder of the genuine bonds that can form in the spotlight and beyond.
