In a shocking move that has sent ripples through the baseball world, Detroit Tigers head coach A.J. Hinch has made the bold decision to bench three key players—Javier Báez, Spencer Torkelson, and Colt Keith—for a critical matchup against the Colorado Rockies, just days before the 2025 MLB playoffs. Hinch, known for his no-nonsense approach, reportedly lost confidence in the trio after observing what he called “unacceptable laziness” during recent practice sessions, according to sources close to the team.
The Tigers, clinging to a wild-card spot with a 79-76 record, are in a do-or-die phase as the regular season winds down. The game against the Rockies, a team fighting for their own postseason hopes, is seen as a must-win to secure Detroit’s playoff berth. Hinch’s decision to sideline Báez, Torkelson, and Keith—three players expected to anchor the lineup—has sparked heated debate among fans and analysts alike.
Sources say Hinch was particularly frustrated during a Tuesday practice when Báez, a two-time All-Star, was seen joking instead of focusing on fielding drills. Torkelson, who has struggled with consistency despite a strong 2025, reportedly skipped extra batting practice, while Keith, the promising rookie, was caught scrolling on his phone during a team meeting. “I need players who are all-in, especially now,” Hinch said in a fiery press conference. “If you’re not giving 100%, you’re not playing. It’s that simple.”
The decision has divided the Tigers’ fanbase. On X, some praised Hinch’s tough stance, with one user posting, “Hinch is sending a message! No one’s bigger than the team.” Others, however, fear the move could jeopardize Detroit’s postseason chances, especially without Báez’s veteran presence and Torkelson’s power at the plate. “Benching Javy and Tork right now is insane. We need them to beat Colorado!” another fan wrote.
Hinch plans to replace the trio with utility player Zach McKinstry, rookie outfielder Wenceel Pérez, and veteran Matt Vierling, all of whom have shown hustle in recent games. While the replacements are capable, none carry the star power or experience of the benched players, raising concerns about the Tigers’ offensive output against Rockies ace Kyle Freeland.
The fallout from Hinch’s decision could have lasting implications. Báez, already under scrutiny for his $140 million contract, faces renewed criticism, while Torkelson’s benching adds fuel to rumors of a potential trade. Keith, despite his youth, risks losing Hinch’s trust at a pivotal moment in his career. As the Tigers prepare for the Rockies showdown, all eyes are on Hinch to see if his gamble pays off—or costs Detroit their playoff dreams.
For now, the message is clear: in Hinch’s clubhouse, effort is non-negotiable, and no star is above accountability.
